Many people are looking for speakers to use with their television or computer, but often they are conflicted about which type of speaker they should purchase.
The debate between Active Vs Passive Speakers is widespread, with some people claiming that passive speakers are quieter, while others claim this is not the case. So, what is the right in this statement? Let Hookeaudio show you the best answer in this article.
- 1 What Are Passive Speakers?
- 2 What are Active Speakers?
- 3 Passive and Active Speakers: Which is better?
- 4 What About Active Speakers and Streaming?
- 5 Best Active Speakers
- 6 Best Passive Speakers
- 7 Active and Passive Speakers: Conclusion
What Are Passive Speakers?
The source component is the part of the kit that plays the music. It can be a CD player or music streamer, a record player, or even a phone or computer. The following section is the preamplifier. This switches between sources and adjusts the volume.
To increase the output of your record player to line level and equalize the signal before feeding it into the preamp circuit, you will also need a Phono Stage. (We’ve removed the phono stage from our diagram to make things simpler).
You will need some muscle to take the signal from the preamp and make it sufficient to drive passive speakers. Say hello to the power amp. This isn’t connected directly to the speaker’s drive units.
The crossover filter network splits the signal to the tweeter and all other frequencies to the larger mid/bass unit.
A three-way speaker will have the crossover splitting the sound into three parts: treble, bass, and midrange.
The crossover network does not require a power source and is therefore considered passive. This is the signal path for a passive setup.
Pros and Cons
We have fewer wires/ It is easier to place
Passive speakers only require a speaker wire connection. An active speaker must be connected to an AC power source. If you don’t want extension cords running around your living space, you will need to ensure that the plug is close to a wall outlet.
Passive speakers tend to be easier to place because speaker wire is usually sold in 100-foot spools. Another thing to remember is that powered passive speakers for home theater will require a second cable from the preamp/processor.
This means you will have two lines to connect to the speaker: one from the wall outlet and another from your pre/pro.
If you’re wiring from a smartphone or other device, that’s fine. But if the source of your audio is far away, you will need to run twice as many wires to an active speaker than a passive system one.
It’s easier to replace/upgrade an amp.
If you need more power or want to go from Product, Opinion device, Gas, Camera lens or Circle, Lens, Font or Camerasolid state tube, or Class A/B/C to Class D, you can use a passive speaker.
Go to the store and purchase a new amp. Then hook it up to your powered speakers. Boom, upgraded! It isn’t easy to upgrade an active speaker.
In some cases, it may even be impossible. It’s not easy to upgrade an amp. The amp should match the specifications of the speaker.
You may improve it, but the manufacturer probably included the amp because the passive speaker required it. To avoid an expensive doorstop, it is necessary to replace the amp that powers an active speaker.
The manufacturer may have replacement amps available, and the job is not too tricky without damaging the cabinet.
Sometimes both can be true, but it is more common for powered speakers with many years of service to have one or the other.
There is a good chance parts have been discontinued. If the speaker is out of warranty, you will need to replace the whole unit. Other cases may offer replacement amps, but these are not easily swappable.
In such cases, you will need to return the speaker to the manufacturer for the technician to install the amp. If this happens, you might be responsible for shipping costs and labor.
They are usually lighter in weight.
A Passive speaker is lighter than an active speaker because they don’t come with built-in external amplifiers. This is more true for traditional Class A/B amps than for Class D amps, such as those used in our active speakers tend at Aperion.
These amps are very light. It may be challenging to mount a dynamic speaker in your home if it uses a Class A/B amplifier, typically a large heat sink.
If you don’t have the knowledge or experience to choose a suitable own amplifier for your powered speakers, it can be challenging to find the correct power rating and impedance. Our PA experts in-store can help!
Signal loss is more likely if there are many powered speakers in the room. Signal loss occurs when the distance between amplifier and speaker exceeds 18.5ft.
This can often hurt your sound quality if you have a large setup using standard loudspeaker wire. Make sure to buy high-quality loudspeaker cables.
What are Active Speakers?
The system is active until the preamp stage. The preamp’s signal is sent to a dynamic crossover network. This performs the same function as the crossover network in a passive setup, but it operates at speaker level (around 15-35v).
Lower signal levels allow components to be optimized for precision and not power handling. This design uses typically active components. On more advanced products, line-level signal processing (digital or digital) is used to extract the most out of the drive units.
This results in a filter network that is potentially more precise and produces a better-integrated and optimized audio system.
Each frequency band is sent to a separate power amp, which then feeds as many drive units responsible for delivering the high frequencies.
Pros and Cons
The Speaker and Amp are designed to be used together.
You will usually be locked into an amp enclosure when you have an active speaker. This is not necessarily a problem, and in fact, it can be a good thing if the speaker has been well designed.
The speaker drivers, active crossover network, and amp were all specifically chosen to work together, so you don’t need to worry about under or overpowering the speaker.
The Aperion Guide to Crossovers provides more information on crossovers and their workings. It is possible to blow out any speaker. However, it should be more challenging if the amp was designed explicitly for that speaker.
You can also get better performance from an active speaker, particularly in output and bass extension. You can generally drive a dynamic speaker somewhat hard without damaging it.
Wireless Applications are possible with active speakers.
You can transmit a wireless signal to an active system using the following fonts: Rectangle, Parallel, and Circle. We can’t yet wirelessly share power, so we still have to rely on cables to transmit any amplified signal.
Wireless control seems like something that is always in the future but never actually materializes. This 2014 article claims that wireless power is now available. Yet, neither you nor I have wireless control in the house.
Although I am sure, it will, any wireless signal path, whether Bluetooth or WiFi, must be amplified before our ears can hear it. If you only want to set up your Bluetooth-enabled device and the active models, with nothing else between, then that speaker must be active.
Many AVRs now have Bluetooth capabilities, but many people don’t want an AVR. They want to stream audio to a speaker.
There are many Bluetooth speakers on the market, including our Allaire Bookshelves. They are wireless and active so that you can connect active speakers to your smartphone TV and stream.
Because an active powered speaker comes with an amplifier built-in, it can be heavier to transport. This can quickly become tedious for touring bands.
If you place active PA speakers in a permanent setting, you might need to have an engineer come to your home to repair the amplifier. The integrated amplifier is located inside the speakers, so you will need to replace the whole unit.
You can’t simply replace the damaged part of your active PA systems are down. You will have to send the entire speaker for repair.
Passive and Active Speakers: Which is better?
Active speakers offer many advantages on paper. The crossover design of active speakers gives designers much more control over the line-level signal path and is less susceptible to distortion and losses than passive filters.
The power amplifier is built into the design so it can be optimized for a particular drive unit. It’s usually built into the box, so there is no need to run speaker cables between them. This eliminates any distortion caused by wires. It’s easier to control and grip.
While these benefits seem to give active speakers an advantage, there are downsides. Since not many speaker manufacturers can provide amplification, the best option is to purchase modules from an OEM supplier.
Although this is a good idea in principle, implementation can often be a problem. This means that the final active speaker’s sound performance is not as high as the active speaker should be.
The shop floor perceives active speakers as less valuable than passive ones. Although their electronics are hidden, there will be a noticeable price premium over similar-looking passive pa speakers.
When you break down the costs, it is often clear that the active option is more cost-effective. A simple passive speaker needs four mono power amplifiers, while a passive set can use one stereo amp to power its four drive units.
Active designs limit the number of upgrades that are possible. It’s not enough to replace power amps. The whole system must be replaced.
This leaves little room for enthusiasts to mix and match. Either you accept the external power amplifier/speaker combo as a whole, or you don’t.
While all active speakers can be considered powered, not all powered speakers need to be called dynamic.
A powered speaker is different because it has the same audio signal path and external amplifier as a passive speaker. Still, the amplifying elements (often both pre-and a power amplifier) are hidden within one of the speaker enclosures. A passive speaker cable will be connected between the slave (passive) and master speaker.
This configuration is the most common for affordable powered models. This configuration has some of its advantages, but it doesn’t have the technical benefits. These are the differences between active and passive speakers.
What About Active Speakers and Streaming?
Active speakers offer clear benefits in terms of performance, but their compactness makes them attractive for users who want a discreet and more compact way to listen to music.
Active speakers are becoming more sophisticated. They can be packed with more functionality, including amplification and streaming modules. This creates a complete system that is streamlined without the need to use extra boxes or cables.
They combine features such as preamp capabilities, digital inputs, and Bluetooth streaming compatibility with active speakers. (Or a small accompanying case that communicates with them) and offer an easy, compact, and hassle-free alternative to separates.
Although Active and Passive Speakers can be more affordable than purchasing everything separately, you should not expect the same performance as a similar-priced collection of class-leading separates.
Best Active Speakers
- Power output (RMS): 15W×2 (tweeter) +, 18W×2 (mid-bass driver)
- Input sensitivity: Line In1: 700±50mV; Line In2: 550±50mV
- Dimension: 154mm × 254mm × 214mm (W×H×D）
- Net weight: 6.6kg
- Frequency response: 60Hz-20kHz
The R1700BT is packaged in a plain retail box. It’s a simple cardboard box with a few pictures of the speakers.
The inside is just as essential with no presentation and basic packaging materials. It’s okay; it keeps them affordable and ensures they can survive shipping to you.
- Size: 6.5″
- Weight 49.00lbs
- Technology Dolby Atmos
- Type Floorstanding
- Frequency Range 38 Hz – 21 kHz (+-3dB)
- Dimension 17.30×9.45×40.00
The design of Klipsch R-625FA can be described as modern technology. The speaker is a premium quality product and is well-made. It looks elegant and shiny.
Best Passive Speakers
- Power: 200W
- Frequency responsiveness: 50Hz – 20,000 Hz
- Connectivity: 3.5mm AUX jack, RCA phono switch, Bluetooth
- Remote control, buttons
- Dimension: 13.98 6.89 inches x 10.71 inch
- Weight: 17.64lbs
- Warranty: 2 Years
The remote is the main accessory. This remote control is an upgraded version of the one that came with the YU6 speakers. We think it’s professional sound. You can adjust your volume, inputs, and EQ with this remote control.
- Enclosure Type: 2-way vented
- Woofer: 5.25″ (13.34 cm) d (Round) Dynamic Balance mineral-filled polymer composite cone driver – Mid/Woofer
- Tweeter: 0.75″ (1.91 cm) d (Round) Dynamic Balance silk/polymer composite dome – Tweeter
- Nominal Impedance: 8 ohms
- Sensitivity: 89 dB (1w/1m)
- Lower and Upper -3dB Limits: 65 Hz → 20 kHz
The T15 sound system arrived in a well-packed box. They were placed between two giant foam pieces inside the box and covered with soft plastic bags. This speaker system looks great with grilles. The Polk emblem and slight curvature of grilles add style.
Active and Passive Speakers: Conclusion
Active speakers can be more expensive than passive speakers, and most audio experts suggest using passive speakers with most audio systems. Active speakers are better for audio professionals and hardcore audio enthusiasts.
They can provide a much clearer sound than passive speakers and do not need to be plugged into an audio source.
Passive speakers are the cheaper option for most audio systems, and they do not produce as much noise as active speakers. We hope that our article can help you know what is the difference between active vs passive speakers.
Video: active vs passive speakers